Therapist factors play a crucial role in the effectiveness of psychotherapy. The ability to understand and respond to clinical material is often influenced by the therapist’s personality and clinical symptomatology. A recent study conducted by Andrew J. Lewis, Vance Locke, Brody Heritage, and Sarah Seddon aimed to identify the specific features of personality and clinical symptomatology that predict a trainee therapist’s rating of cognitive behavioural (CB) and psychodynamic interpersonal (PI) processes in therapy sessions.
What factors predict a trainee therapist’s rating of cognitive behavioural and dynamic interpersonal therapy processes?
The study sought to determine which aspects of trainee therapist personality and clinical symptomatology influenced their rating of cognitive behavioural and dynamic interpersonal therapy processes. The researchers specifically focused on how trainee therapists differentiated between CB and PI processes when watching video recordings of therapy sessions.
What is the role of personality and clinical symptomatology in trainee therapist ratings?
The study found that trainee therapists’ personality traits and clinical symptomatology significantly influenced their ratings of psychotherapy processes. The most consistent predictor of variance in ratings was hypomanic activation, which was associated with higher ratings of all psychotherapy processes in both CB and PI conditions. Other factors, such as Aggressiveness-Revised and personality scales of Psychoticism-Revised and Negative Emotionality/Neuroticism-Revised, also showed some notable but less consistent predictions.
What questionnaire was used to assess personality?
To assess trainee therapist personality, the study utilized the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory-2-Restructured Form (MMPI-2-RF). This widely used questionnaire assesses various aspects of personality and psychopathology, providing valuable insights into the trainees’ mental health and potential areas of concern.
How accurate were the trainees in differentiating cognitive behavioural from psychodynamic interpersonal process?
The trainees demonstrated a significant level of accuracy in differentiating between cognitive behavioural (CB) and psychodynamic interpersonal (PI) processes. When watching the CB session, the trainees accurately distinguished the CB process. However, interestingly, they rated the CB video higher in PI processes than the actual PI video itself. This finding suggests that trainees may have been more influenced by the overall therapeutic process rather than the specific therapeutic approach demonstrated in the videos.
What were the main findings of the study?
The key findings of the study indicate that trainee therapist ratings of psychotherapy processes are influenced by certain clinical symptoms and personality factors. Hypomanic activation (RC9) consistently predicted higher ratings of all psychotherapy processes, indicating its potential impact on the trainees’ perception and evaluation of therapy. Other clinical and personality factors such as Aggressiveness-Revised, Psychoticism-Revised, and Negative Emotionality/Neuroticism-Revised showed some lesser but still notable predictions.
The study also revealed that the MMPI-2-RF scales accounted for variabilities in psychotherapy process ratings ranging from 15% to 51%. This suggests that trainee therapist personality and clinical symptomatology contribute significantly to how they perceive and rate therapeutic processes.
It is important to note that while this study provides valuable insights into the role of trainee therapist personality and clinical symptomatology in the rating of cognitive behavioural and dynamic interpersonal therapy processes, further research is needed to confirm and expand upon these findings. Future studies may explore the relationship between therapist factors and treatment outcomes, as well as the potential implications for therapist selection and training.
Overall, this research highlights the crucial role of trainee therapist personality and clinical symptomatology in shaping their perception and evaluation of psychotherapy processes. Understanding these factors can aid in the development of effective therapist training programs and contribute to improved mental health outcomes for patients.
Source: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/cpp.2730
Leave a Reply